Is Brighter Shores a Dead Game or Just Getting Started?

Published in News on January 8th, 2025

If you've spent any time in the Brighter Shores community recently, especially on Reddit, you've probably noticed a recurring theme: the player count. Screenshots and posts analyzing the number of concurrent players seem to dominate the discussion, with many pointing out that the player count has now dipped below 1,000 for the first time since launch. For a brand-new MMO, this has sparked a debate: is the game already doomed, or is this just a rough patch in its early days?

"The Game Is Dead"

For some players, the low numbers are a glaring red flag. A game that's barely out of the gate and struggling to hold onto its player base doesn't inspire confidence. Many have taken this as a sign that Brighter Shores won't recover.

Some of these concerns stem from unmet expectations. A portion of the community came into the game expecting something akin to RuneScape. When Brighter Shores turned out to be its own thing, with mechanics and design choices that set it apart, many players felt alienated. Complaints about the game's state-bugs, limited content, and other early-access woes-have only added to the exodus.

Then there's the marketing issue. Or rather, the lack of it. For a niche MMO without a big studio behind it, a robust player base is often built on word of mouth. But when the numbers are this low, it creates a vicious cycle: fewer players means less buzz, which means even fewer new players giving the game a shot. To some, this all spells disaster.

"It's Early Days"

On the flip side, there's a sizable chunk of the community that sees the current situation as nothing more than growing pains. These players point out that Brighter Shores is in early access-a phase meant for testing, refining, and fixing the very issues that critics are upset about.

Andrew and the team at Fen Research have been transparent about their vision and their long-term commitment to the game. In a recent Q&A, FenSamuel addressed the concerns head-on:

"Fen Research has no plans to shut down Brighter Shores. The team is committed to improving the game and believes in its long-term potential, regardless of player numbers."

This reassurance has resonated with the game's supporters, many of whom are willing to stick around and give the team the time they need. They see the low player count as temporary, something that will naturally improve as the game gets better and moves toward full release.

Two Sides of the Same Coin

The debate ultimately comes down to perspective. For some, low player numbers are a dealbreaker, a sign that the game has failed to capture an audience. For others, it's part of the process, especially for a small team working on a passion project without the resources of a major studio.

What's undeniable is that Brighter Shores is at a pivotal moment. If Fen Research can address the community's concerns, deliver meaningful updates, and continue to communicate openly, the game has a real chance to grow. Whether the player base is tiny or thriving, the heart of Brighter Shores will depend on its developers and the loyal community that believes in its potential.

You Might Also Like

Everything You Need to Know from the Brighter Shores AMA with Samuel

Get a detailed summary of the Brighter Shores AMA with Fen Research's Samuel, covering gameplay updates, future content, trading, raids, and community insights.

Ryan
2 Days Ago 26 Min Read

Exploring the Possible Origins of Fen Research's Name

Exploring the possible inspirations behind Fen Research's name, from its ties to Cambridgeshire's Fens to its connection to RuneScape's MUD roots and innovation in game design.

Ryan
2 Weeks Ago 3 Min Read

Hopeport Recreated At 80% Scale In Neverwinter Nights 2

A dedicated fan has recreated Hopeport at 80% scale in Neverwinter Nights 2, showcasing the civilised port-town area of Episode 1 in Brighter Shores as part of their passion project.

Ryan
3 Weeks Ago 13 Min Read

Players Share Constructive Feedback on Brighter Shores Early Access

Brighter Shores players share their feedback on professions, progression, passive activities, and quality-of-life improvements, aiming to shape the game's future.

Ryan
3 Weeks Ago 4 Min Read